"What is my business worth?" is usually the first question an owner asks when they start thinking about selling. It is also one of the most misunderstood. Your business is not worth what you need for retirement, what a friend got for theirs, or a fixed percentage of sales. It is worth what a qualified buyer will pay and a lender will finance, based on the cash flow it produces and the risk of keeping that cash flow going.
This guide explains how small, owner-operated businesses in Buffalo and Western New York are typically valued, so you can go into the process with realistic expectations.
Start with cash flow, not sales
Two businesses with the same sales can be worth very different amounts. What matters most to a buyer of a Main Street business is how much money the business produces for one full-time owner. Brokers usually call this Seller's Discretionary Earnings (SDE).
SDE generally starts with the net profit on your tax return or profit and loss statement and adds back:
- The owner's salary or draws (for one owner)
- Interest and depreciation
- Personal expenses run through the business, such as a personal vehicle or phone
- True one-time expenses, such as a major repair that will not repeat
The key word is documented. Buyers and lenders will want to see each add-back supported by your records. Cash income that does not show up on tax returns generally will not be counted, which is one of the most common sources of disappointment for sellers.
Larger businesses with a management team in place are often valued on EBITDA instead, but for most owner-operated businesses in WNY, SDE is the starting point.
From cash flow to price: multiples
Once SDE is established, it is usually multiplied by a factor to arrive at a value range. That multiple is not a fixed number. It depends on how risky a buyer thinks the cash flow is and how much demand exists for that type of business. Rules of thumb you may find online can be a rough reference, but they vary widely and do not account for your specific business.
Factors that tend to support a higher multiple:
- Steady or growing sales and profit over several years
- Clean, consistent books that match tax returns
- A business that runs without the owner doing everything
- A long, assignable lease at a reasonable rent, or owned real estate
- Equipment in good condition
- Licenses, contracts or a brand that a buyer can keep
- Strong local demand for that type of business
Factors that tend to push the multiple lower:
- Declining or unpredictable earnings
- Heavy reliance on the owner's personal relationships or skills
- Customer concentration, where a few customers make up much of the revenue
- A short lease or an uncooperative landlord
- Deferred maintenance or aging equipment
- Unresolved legal, environmental or licensing issues
Real estate, inventory and equipment
How the deal is structured affects the number you hear.
Real estate. If you own the building, it is often valued separately from the business, based on what the property would be worth as real estate. Some owners sell both together; others keep the property and lease it to the buyer. Each option changes the price, the buyer pool and the financing.
Inventory. In many retail sales, such as convenience stores, liquor stores and gas stations, inventory is counted at closing and paid for on top of the business price. Make sure you know whether a quoted value includes inventory or not.
Equipment, fixtures and furniture. These are normally included in the business price. Their condition matters more than their original cost, because a buyer will factor in what they will need to repair or replace soon.
Industry details matter
Different businesses have different value drivers. For example:
- Gas stations and convenience stores: fuel gallons and margin, inside sales, the fuel supply agreement, and the condition and compliance of tanks. See our gas station seller guide.
- Liquor and wine stores: sales history, lease, license history and the buyer's ability to get State Liquor Authority approval. See selling a liquor store in New York.
- Hotels and motels: occupancy, average room rates, brand or franchise status, property condition and the real estate. See our guide on selling a hotel or motel in Western New York and our hotel and motel broker services.
A valuation that ignores these details is likely to miss the mark.
Broker opinion of value vs. certified appraisal
There are two common types of valuation, and they serve different purposes.
A broker's opinion of value estimates what your business would likely sell for in today's market, based on your financials, comparable sales and current buyer demand. It is usually free when you are considering a sale, and it is aimed at setting a realistic asking price.
A certified business appraisal is a formal written report prepared by a credentialed appraiser. It is typically required for things like estate and gift tax filings, divorces, partner disputes and some lending situations. It costs more and takes longer.
If your goal is to sell, a broker's opinion of value is normally the right first step. If you need a valuation for legal or tax reasons, talk to a certified appraiser or your CPA.
How to raise your value before you sell
Some of the most effective steps are simple, but they take time, which is why planning ahead pays off:
- Keep books that clearly match your tax returns, and stop running personal expenses through the business where possible
- Document your add-backs as you go
- Reduce how much the business depends on you by training staff and writing down key processes
- Secure or extend your lease
- Fix obvious maintenance issues and keep equipment records
- Keep licenses, permits and compliance records current and organized
Find out what your business is worth
Turbo Business Brokers provides free, confidential valuations for business owners in Buffalo, Niagara Falls, Rochester and across Western New York. Our team has hands-on experience owning and operating businesses in the region, so we look at your business the way a buyer will.
- Try our business value calculator for a quick starting range
- Request a free, confidential valuation from a broker
- Read our step-by-step guide on how to sell a business in Buffalo
- Buyers interested in our listings can sign our NDA to see full details
- Call (716) 265-0409
This guide is general information and not legal, tax or financial advice. A broker's opinion of value is not a certified appraisal.